Astronomical Ballooning
Written by Sten Odenwald
Copyright (C) 1984 Kalmbach Publishing. Reprinted by permission

 

This web page is located at the Astronomy Cafe

http://www.astronomycafe.net

Astronomy Cafe


When I first joined the Center for Astrophysics/ University of Arizona infrared program some 5 years ago, I had no firsthand experience with 'ballooning' and only the vaguist notion of how it was done. This situation did not really change until I traveled with the rest of the 'balloon crew' to a quiet little town in eastern Texas called Palestine. A casual glance at this community wouldn't show it to be much different in geography or temperment from its neighbors, but during the prime months for scientific ballooning between May and October the situation changes dramatically. You might hear the motels and restaurants echoing with conversations of 'scintillation counters', 'bolometers', 'cryogenics' and 'ground loops', spoken in crisp tongues very different than the leasurly Texan inflections.
The center of the scientific activity is a small group of buildings just off route 287 outside of Palestine called the National Scientific Balloon Facility or the 'balloon base' for short. This is the workplace of some 61 engineers, technicians, secretaries and administrators who oversee the ballooning needs of the scientists who come from all parts of the world just to use these facilities.

My first impression of the balloon base was muted by its low-key operation. The real drama of ballooning occurs only during those 2 or 3 times a week that a launch is in progress. The rest of the time, the scientists are busy, sometimes working 16 hours a day, tending to their instruments while the NSBF staff attend to the details of maintaining and operating the base.

Why do astronomers use balloons? Very simply, we want our instruments to get as high as possible above the screening affect of the earths atmosphere. To do this, some astronomers have outfitted a C-141 jet, the Kuiper Airborne Observatory, with sensitive infrared detectors and fly at altitudes of nearly 8 miles. Satellites like IRAS have also been launched from Cape Canaveral. Infrared astronomers also use balloon-borne platforms, carrying large telescopes and sensitive infrared sensors.

Until recently, the astronomers could only look at the granduer of the universe through a few windows in the electromagnetic spectrum, such as the optical or radio, where the atmosphere was more or less transparent. Occasionally, we could find a high mountain top where the 'seeing' through one of the other windows, such as the ultraviolet or infrared, was only partly obscurred. Twenty five years of space exploration have shown us what an unobstructed view looks like but only at great expense. Also, the instruments that must be used in satellites such as IRAS are at least 5 years out of date by the time they are flown.

By flying instruments on balloon-borne platforms, not only can we beat the staggering costs of multi-million dollar rocket launches but the instruments can also be rapidly up-graded to keep up with developments in detector technology. The 'cycle time' can be very short so that several flights can be performed every year provided that the instruments are not severly damaged.

THE TELESCOPE

The far-infrared instruments we use are similar to those that optical astronomers use. A large mirror gives us the light gathering ability to see faint objects and to resolve them in detail. Our 102-cm, F/13.7 cassegrain reflector in an altitude-azimuth mounting serves this purpose admirably and is the largest far-infrared telescope being used in this way in the world. The mirror itself is actually made of an aluminum aloy called TENZALLOY and is about 8 inches thick at the center but only 1/2 inch thick at its circumference. The entire surface is nickle coated and figured to a spherical shape. Anyone who has ever used a telescope knows that because of the earths rotation, a star will drift out of the eyepiece field unless the telescope is driven mechanically to keep up with the stars diurnal motion. The gyros on the telescope keep it in 'inertial space' so that the effects of star field motion due to earth rotation are automatically suppressed.

To find out where the telescope is pointing, we use a wide field TV camera strapped to the telescope and a 35 mm film camera that photographs the region of the sky where our telescope is pointing. A bright planet like mars is a very strong infrared source and provides us with information about where the detectors are pointing and their sensitivity to a known source of radiation.

The telescope is normally operated in either the 'raster' mode or more recently the 'point-and-integrate' mode. The former has been our workhorse over the last decade and with it we can map areas of the sky, 4 times as large as the full moon in as little as 20 minutes. With point-and-integrate mode, we can see objects 10-20 times fainter than ever before since staring at a single part of the sky for a longer time and lets us gather more far-infrared radiation.

All of the instructions that we send to the payload are transmitted 'up-link' to a device called a command decoder that communicates with the other electrical sub-systems onboard to activate motors, change the pointing direction, turn on amplifiers and so on. The digitized data sent 'down-link' are recorded on magnetic tape and particular system functions, such as the battery current, are displayed during the flight on strip-chart recorders. The down-link telemetry rate is 40,960 bits per second so that during a typical 8 hour flight we gather over 1.2 billion bits of data. This is about the same amount of information that is stored in a 24 volumn set of the Encyclopedia Britanica and occupies about 20, 2500' magnetic tapes.

DETECTORS

The detectors are the astronomers retinae which measure the intensity of the far-infrared radiation. These are usually chips of a special material that change their resistence depending on how hot the incoming radiation makes them. The resulting change in voltage, when amplified 1000s of times, tells us how bright the object is that is heating the detector. Since the detector only operates when it is very cold, it must be cooled in a cryogenic dewar to liquid helium temperatures of 1.8 K. The detectors are so sensitive that after 1 minute of staring at a particular part of the sky, we can detect 10(-14) watts/m2. To understand how little this is, in principle, we could 'see' the heat given off by a person sitting on a snow bank from a distance of nearly 40 miles! In astronomical terms, we can also see the most luminous, dust obscurred stars that are formed in dense clouds anywhere in the Galaxy.

'THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS A FREE LUNCH'

As you might well imagine, astronomical research is an expensive undertaking. Our payload was designed and assembled by engineers at the Center for Astrophysics between 1971 and 1973 using in-house research and development funds. Since then, $100,000 has been obtained on a yearly basis to maintain, upgrade and launch the payload and to pay the salaries of the scientists and engineers. A typical observing campaign to Palestine can cost $20,000 for the balloon, $10,000 for the helium to fill it and between $10,000 and $15,000 for food, lodging and transportation for the 10 scientists and enginers during a 3 week observing session. The detectors themselves change every few flights and are maintained by separate funds provided by the scientists or by the NASA research grant. A detector chip, its amplifiers and cryogenic dewar can cost between $4000 and $10,000 for a simple, 1-element bolometer system to as much as $500,000 for a two band, far-infrared spectrometer system. The money is obtained through a formal proposal submitted to NASA by Dr. Giovanni Fazio during the year prior to the intended year of the observing 'campaign'.

In the face of the recent IRAS successes, our group will have to re-evaluate its goals and strike-out in directions other than those that originally established our program during the infant years of infrared astronomy. Although we continue to have the advantage of higher angular resolution, the next generation of our experiments must rely on much more that this.

LAUNCH DAY

After 3 weeks of troubleshooting finiky electronics and double checking the telemetry to make sure there's no electrical interference, we have the payload more or less 'buttoned-up' and ready for flight. The meteorologist at the 11:00 AM briefing has told us that the weather looks promising; the surface winds will be about 3 mph at launch and the sky is clear at the balloon base and at the recovery site. The 250 mile track that the balloon is expected to take will be a gentil arc from here to somewhere near Lubock, Texas. The launch vehicle, 'Tiny Tim' a 10 ton, diesel-powered, behemoth with wheels 8 feet tall, picks up our gondola at 1 PM and drives the 1/2 mile stretch down to the launch pad at the pace of a brisk walk. After one last check-out on the launch pad, the balloon is brought out in a large wooden crate on the back of a truck; the 'tie down' and helium tank vehicles are brought out as well. One hour before the flight, our checkout is complete and the balloon and parachute have been carefully unfolded. Although it weighs 2 tons, the balloon is exquisitely delicate: Made entirely of tough, thin plastic, the nylon straps or 'gores' support the full, 2 ton weight of our payload. If human fingers apply too much pressure to the fabric when it is unfolded, a tear will eminate from that point and shread the entire balloon once the full weight of the payload bears down on it. In seconds a balloon will dissolve into an undulating sea of plastic covering an area the size of a football field. The unlucky, multi -million dollar payload that was released before this happens would be dragged across the launch pad into the surrounding forest and may have to be completely re-built.

Just before launch, two men carrying snake-like hoses from the helium truck begin the inflation of the balloon through plastic filling tubes attached to the top of the balloon. During inflation, the upper 1/3 of the balloon is held down securely by the tie-down vehicle. Inflation usually takes about 45 minutes and sounds like a small jet reving up for takeoff as the helium gas is transfered from the tank truck into the cavernous volume of the balloon. Following inflation, the roar of the helium through the inflation hoses ceases, the two men tie-off the filling tubes with a few overhand knots and back away from the balloon that rises over 100 feet above their heads. There is complete silence. The balloon sways gently in the twilight, everyone crosses their fingers and when all is clear, the launch command is given. The tie-down vehicle releases the balloon; it rises, fluttering almost noislessly in the wind and ascends quickly until it is almost above the payload. Tiny Tim moves with amazing speed and agility for a few moments to get the payload directly under the balloon and then releases it. The payload, at the end of its balloon and parachute train swings to and fro like a giant pendulum and is slowly lost in the encroaching night sky. It shines briefly like a bright star as it catches the dwindeling rays of the setting sun high above the earth which, to us ground dwellers, had already set long ago. The NSBF launch crew return to their homes to have dinner, play with their children and watch TV while the scientists and NSBF tracking crew remain behind, their day has just begun and the universe this night is about to reveal yet another of its secrets.

What follows is a 2 hour lull during which the balloon continues to ascend until it reaches its appointed 'float' altitude some 95,000' above the earth. At this altitude, the atmosphere provides 100 times less pressure than at sea level and the temperature is a 'nippy' -90 F. We actually have to supply heating pads to some of our equipment to get them to work at all! At float, the telescope is 'un-stowed' and we move to the first object on our schedule, hopefully a planet, for that all-important calibration. The schedule is planned well in advance. Unlike the romantic notion of scientists who somehow accidentally discover some new magical chemical or a 'new star' in the sky, astronomers embark on premeditated journeys of exploration. To a large degree, we have to know what we are looking for before we find it. The sky is much too vast for us to waste our limited time on regions that will not bear the kind of fruit we are looking for. After all, you don't look for whales in the middle of the desert! So, we look at regions of the sky like the Milky Way where we know star forming regions are found in great quantity. We look at regions that radio astronomers say are filled with hot molecular gas. We look at near-by galaxies that are known to be dusty and luminous from optical studies by other astronomers. If we are lucky, we see something that no one has ever seen before, or have probably not seen clearly enough to understand what it was that they were looking at.

As the night unfolds and we step through our list of 10 to 15 targets, we see how each one is different from the other. Some are just single, diffuse blobs of invisible warm dust that our sensitive detectors say is suspended between the stars we see on our TV screen. Others may show individual hot spots scattered over an area as large as the full moon. We watch the squiggles of the strip chart pens as they rise to announce some new enigma just discovered and fall to tell us there's nothing more to be seen here! Sometimes, just when we think there are no more new sources to be found during one raster through a region, the pens move suggestively once again! A mixture of excitement and pain accompanies our realization that we must move on to the next target, a move we have already delayed twice in the last 5 minutes.

After 8 to 10 hours of observing, we have accumulated 20 magnetic tapes of data; the parachute is 'cut-down' from the balloon and unfolds to break the descent of our 2 ton payload. There are an unending number of stories about where payloads have landed: in the alligator-infested swamps of Louisiana, the backyards of expensive homes, in lakes or dense forests. In fact, there are even stories about how rural farmers have actually shot at balloons and their fragile payloads, no doubt thinking that they were sent by aliens from outer space! In spite of the many hazards, natural and man-made, our payload always seems to make it back in one piece, ready for the next launch.

Recovering the flight film from the star field camera completes the data taking operation of a successful flight and, after packing up the flight control electronics and 'moth balling' the gondola until next time, we return to our respective institutions to study the scientific data, make our maps and write-up our discoveries. After a year, we are ready and anxious to do it all over again with a new set of targets!